The commercial printing industry is hurtling toward a high-stakes collision between Silicon Valley hype and shop-floor reality, as corporate forecasters predict that autonomous AI procurement bots will soon intermediate trillions in B2B spending. While major consultancies claim agentic AI will rapidly automate the vast majority of corporate purchasing, veteran print operators are pushing back against the tech fantasy, pointing out that early AI buyers are often clumsy, technologically incompetent, and prone to generating nonsensical manufacturing requests. This deepening controversy exposes a sharp divide over whether algorithmic sourcing is an impending industrial revolution that legacy print shops must urgently adapt to, or merely an expensive distraction driven by software developers who fundamentally misunderstand how print is made.