Ninestar’s video attacking HP conveniently leaves out some of the most controversial issues surrounding the company, including widespread counterfeiting in the millions and U.S. restrictions tied to forced-labor concerns. While the video attempts to portray Ninestar as a defender of consumers and the printing industry, it avoids addressing serious questions surrounding its own business practices and products. The glaring omission raises an uncomfortable question: is Ninestar attacking HP to expose wrongdoing—or to distract from the allegations, controversies, and what critics describe as a corrupt business model of its own?