- This topic is empty.
-
Posts
-
A new Money Legends YouTube video ( made by marketlegends90@gmail.com in Mexico), “HP Charges $60 for Ink. China Found a $3 Fix,” is putting the spotlight on the growing battle over HP ink cartridges, cartridge chips, printer firmware and China’s massive aftermarket printing-supplies industry. The video reportedly surpassed 41,000 views in roughly one day, highlighting consumer and industry interest in the dramatic price gap between expensive OEM ink cartridges and low-cost compatible alternatives. Although the latest video was produced in Mexico, its themes closely resemble the previously reported Ninestar vs. HP cartridge battle, raising questions about who ultimately controls the multibillion-dollar printer-supplies market. China has developed a huge ecosystem of compatible-cartridge manufacturers, chip developers and aftermarket technology companies, while HP and other OEMs continue using firmware, cartridge authentication, patents and enforcement actions to protect their consumables businesses. For dealers and consumers, the $60-versus-$3 debate is therefore about much more than price—it involves printer firmware, toner and ink chips, patent rights, cartridge authentication and aftermarket competition.
The video rolls out a carefully calculated narrative, casting Ninestar as the plucky underdog fighting a corporate titan while painting HP as an aggressive, monopolistic villain trying to lock down the toner cartridge industry. While Ninestar plays the victim, they conveniently omit the dirty truth about their staggering industrial output: millions of toner and ink units pumped out every single month (most of which are counterfeit). That staggering volume doesn’t even factor in heavy-hitting partners like Printrite, Hubei Dinglong, Aster Graphics, and GPI, whose combined overproduction is actively choking the market in a tidal wave of product glut. And let’s not forget the white-label toner products they quietly churn out for OEMs like Konica Minolta, Ricoh, Sharp and Xerox. Ninestar wants it both ways—crying foul over HP and Canon roadblocks in the U.S. and Europe while quietly vacuuming up massive market share across Asia, South America, and Africa. Ninestar can’t dominate global supply chains while hiding behind an underdog mask, which is the exact reason OEMs like HP are finally drawing a line in the sand.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.